Have to agree with Zombyboy, there are not a lot of pretty people on Idol this season. I suppose we’re meant to take that as sincerity that the producers really are looking for the best voice! Feh. It’s an entire package, and they all bloody well know that.
You see the music is irrelevant in this industry. I’m going to have to ship this ‘wick-prick’ platinum just so teenage girls can have a compact disc cover to get wet with.*
Call me cynical, but you can’t ignore the fact that Iraheta has a face reminiscent of the hind end of a bulldog.
Danny Gokey and his ever-changing facial hair is predictably good, though honestly that first note made my ear hurt. Why the judges (at least two of whom can actually sing) didn’t mention that I don’t know.
CD cover rating: 4 stars (out of 10)
Kris Allen actually made that song – which I despise from way back – listenable. But that mouth, his sideways-sliding mouth that makes him look like a little boy trying to be so cute that mama won’t spank…GAH! Major squick there.
CD cover rating: 2 stars (+8 for those sad, pathetic girls who get off on that little boy bullshit)
Lil Rounds has officially Lost It. That song was all over the fuckin’ map, and she was actually singing slower than the music. Maybe she’s drugged.
CD cover rating: 7 stars (in that outfit)
Anoop Desai, you BORE me. Yes, still. I like that song (though I agree, in Cyndi Lauper’s grating whinge it is much less appealing), but I find it telling that he basically gave himself a vagina whilst singing it. Nut up, boy!
CD cover rating: -423 stars (+433 for the starry-eyed tweenies with a fetish for bug eyes. Sorry about the bug eyes thing, Anoop.)
Scott Macintyre. Jesus GOD can we be done with this walking clitoris already? If it is possible to have negative testosterone, this guy has it. I think the sympathy vote has carried him quite far enough.
CD cover rating: Just EWW
Allison Iraheta can sing, yes, we’ve well-established that. But see above, please, re: ass-end of bulldog, kthx. It ain’t the hair, it ain’t the clothes, it’s the arrangement of features on her face.
CD cover rating: I’m afraid to specify as that’s dark matter territory
Matt Giraud could be 97 times cuter than he currently isn’t and I still wouldn’t listen to that song. That’s one that continually gave me minor finger sprains when in actual rotation, yes, from stabbing at the radio to change it to something ANYTHING else. Stupid fucking song, not helped by a sleazy, wannabe-R&B rendition. (Small wonder Paula and Whassername drooled over it.)
CD cover rating: -5 (+whatever for those who like ferrety-faced potential vampires with waaay too much gum tissue on display)
For Adam Lambert I had to wait to catch his performance on YouTube this morning since both my DVRs are utterly retarded about shows that run over their alloted times. It was good, but I don’t think it rated a standing O from Simon, unless he’s getting in touch with his boy-kissing side. The thing that impresses me most about Adam is his breath control. He never rushes a note, and he holds them, manipulates them, until he is quite ready to move on to the next one. He’s a brilliant musical technician, and manages to never do the same thing twice in a performance. Whether he wins or not, he’s going to be recording (er, “recording”?) with Simon.
CD cover rating: infinity, even if he really does like boys better
*As ever, guess the movie.






